Something you want to get off your chest? Submit a Whinge ›


Ridiculous riddle un-rigourous!

December 9 2019

It’s clever to pace the travellers so their time on the hill has the same average speed for the duration as their flat travel. They are twice as fast coming down in half the time as going up so the average over time is ( 2t x 3kph + 1t x 6kph )/3t= 4kph, it does not change with time t. Time of travel is 6 hours so total distance is 6x4kph = 24 miles. It doesn’t matter how far the top of the hill is so long as they get there in 3 to 4 hours. If there was no hill they get to the middle in 3 hrs, 3hrs back. If it was all hill they get to the top in 4 hrs and turn around to get back in two hours. Or anywhere in between. So what? If you have any maths skills and are trusting you assume the riddle has a solution solvable by simultaneous equations and spend half your morning trying to write them before resorting to graphing it. Time on the horizontal and distance away from start on the vertical. If you shift the steep all hill triangle to the left it intersects the no hill triangle at the same distance from start on both sides.

Phooey on unsolvable riddles!

Please note that care must be taken with the wording of comments. Where possible, avoid negative references to specific businesses or individuals. The Lakes Weekly Bulletin reserves the right to edit or withhold comments. Comments may be reproduced in the printed edition of LWB.

Post your comment



    Keep well away from LSD folks.......or you end up talking like this clown......

    Posted 09/12/2019 2:12pm (7 months ago)

  • I'm no genius

    I'm no maths whiz but I'm pretty sure 6 x 4kph <> 24 miles.. Stay in school kids.

    Posted 13/01/2020 11:13am (6 months ago)


    Surely "I'm No" must mean KILOMETRES rather than MILES ???? just sayin.......

    Posted 26/01/2020 11:36am (5 months ago)